This blog is where you will find community council information, including meeting times, minutes and agenda. Do please comment on postings.

Monday, 26 October 2026

MSCC - Agenda for 28th October 2026

 

M archmont & Sciennes

Community Council




Meeting on Wed 28th October 2026 at 7:30pm

To be held at Sciennes Art Hub, 8a Sciennes Road EH9 1LE

A G E N D A



1 Sederunt and apologies

2   Draft Minutes of last meeting, September 2026

actions and matters arising (not otherwise on the agenda)

3. Presenting Local Place Plan: David Somervell, Banzai Edinburgh

4 Meadows & Bruntsfield Links (report attached)

5 Publicity

6 City Councillor report on topical local issues

7 Inclusion Officer’s report (attached)



Items for discussion

8 Planning

9. Xmas arrangements

For info:

10. Treasurer's report (attached)

11 SMAG report

12 Meetings attended

13 AOCB

Support for MCR pathways (JGHS) and possible speaker in future (letter circulated recently)

15 Date of next meeting: Wednesday 25th November 2026



Please note new venue for the meeting. Access easiest from Sciennes



All who live or work locally are welcome to attend

MSCC - Minutes for June 2026

 

Marchmont and Sciennes Community Council

Minutes of Meeting held on June 24th, 2026 at Sciennes Art Hub, 13 Rillbank Terrace

 

Present: Brian Gilmore, chair; Alison Service, Treasurer. Anne Laing, Secretary; Kate McNairney South Meadows Action Group; Douglas Roger MSCC , Susie Agnew MSCC, Peter Olech, MSCC Richars Shillock MSCC, Anthony Holmes NSCC Bethan Christie local resident; Joanna Storrar Local resident; Margaret Coughtrie local resident; Lorna Slater MSP Edinburgh Central

Apologies: Geoff Parsons, Ian Murray MP, Cllr Steve Burgess, Cllr Ben Parker, Kayleigh Gordon, Cllr Pauline Flannery (report received after the meeting)

Brian opens the meeting at 19.32pm and welcomes everyone.

Draft Minutes of last meeting May 2026. Richard approves. Peter seconds. 

Matters arising: Susie asked Ian Murray MP to pursue the post office further concerning the delivery office now being in Murrayfield and not Morningside. Ian Murray subsequently sent a more rigorous letter to the Post Office but has had no reply yet.

Suzie last month had asked the MSCC to ask the Grange cemetery if they could extend the closing time of 5 pm so that it stay open until 7pm in summer. Alison had written to them but no reply so far.

It had been agreed to donate £150 to SMAG to help with general expenses: Kate has now given Alison the information necessary to process this request.

Talk by Lorna Slater MSP (Green) for Edinburgh Central

Lorna Slater MSP (Green) for Edinburgh Central: Gave a talk to the MSCC on her role within the Government. Her responsibility is Public Service Reform. She outlined ways in which she can help the CCs ie. local constituent problems like housing and social care, and Council liaison. She can put written questions to Parliament and has to hear back within 20 days, or questions to the Chamber but this is less reliable. Parliamentary Motions can raise awareness on issues of concern or celebration. She can help in a facilitating role, ie. aiding a local campaign/public meeting costs etc. Questions put to her included the MSCC concern over the recent Planning approval for an aparthotel in the area despite hundreds of objections – and no way for us to appeal. Douglas to email her details and she will see what she can do. It was put to her that changes to the legislation are needed and certain councillors are and will be liaising with Lorna on this. The Astley Ainslie site was also discussed and it was noted that someone from the AA Trust will attend the MSCC September meeting. Lorna said she will try to meet with that person as well.

Meadows & Bruntsfield Links: The AGM was on June the 19th with a talk given by the first chairman 25 years ago. Alison outlined the work being done (wildflower meadows, lots of new trees planted – needing watering, working with school kids, bench repairs, new playpark equipment, second table tennis table). The Hamish Henderson walkway has been approved by Edinburgh Council and it will go ahead though will take a bit of time for the signage etc. The Meadow’s Festival was 6/7 June. MSCC was with FoMBL in the information tent – Alison participated.

Anne asked for a FoMBL info sheet highlighting the need for volunteers for the MSCC Noticeboard – Alison to provide.

Publicity : No report. The Marchmont Hardware Shop is recently re-opened after repair works and it has been an extremely difficult time for them. However Kayleigh and Leane say the Noticeboards will be looked at shortly with a view to upgrading them.

City Councillor report on topical local issues – General and for Information from Cllr Flannery, sent by email

By-Election, date 3 September: timeframe will also include Council Recess, July.

Edinburgh by Numbers on Council Website: very good background information:

Edinburgh has the second highest number of higher education students per 1,000 residents (140) of all major UK cities, behind Manchester (148)

  • 25% of people moving to Scotland from other countries outside the UK come to live in Edinburgh

  • Ward Profile

  • Population, economy, tourism, environment, transport, housing

Visitor Levy starts 26 July: though funds for this year 26/27 will not reflect a full year’s income because of this start date

Extra funds from the Visitor Levy for extra policing: no timeframe yet as to when this may trickle down: could be something to bear in mind if sending CC representation to Rachel Lumsden’s quarterly forum for Ward interest

This forum is also worth highlighting if there are any local issues, particularly to do with any anti-social behaviour concerns

People will be aware of the incident involving a pedestrian and e-bike/scooter at nearby St Patrick’s Square

Safer Drug Consumption Facility: consultation finishes, 25 June, tomorrow if the CC is wanting to contribute a response to this

Community Grant Fund structure and model is to change with a report coming to Culture & Communities Committee Meeting later in the year, certainly after recess

There is to be a further consultation process on this

Meadows Festival was a great success for the local area: particular shout-out to Marchmont Hardware for their involvement with the Dog Show – a festival highlight

Inclusion Officer’s report : Douglas pointed out that the Local Place Plan is progressing and pointed out the exhibition stands in the room will be displayed at the Climate Festival taking place on the Meadows. People and members of the MSCC are encouraged to add comments.

Sciennes Arts Hub: Progress is being made with our plans to upgrade this -Monitor/TV coming soon. Hybrid meetings for MSCC were discussed but difficulty might be for microphones to pick up those speaking. Maybe a trial/test could be carried out.

Heat Networks: Douglas attended the inaugural meeting last week. Lots of problems to be solved for the hundreds of networks in Edinburgh. Douglas is currently evaluating local heat networks to determine why they are so expensive - this research as part of Lothian heat.

Items for discussion

Planning: No contentious new applications affecting our area.

Argyle Place/Meadows crossing: the issue had been raised by Bethan Morgan, local resident and was taken up by a Councillor. MSCC has since received information from Road Safety that a new system is in place (Pedestrian Crossing Assessment Framework) and a “request a pedestrian crossing “form will be completed by Bethan and Anne

Treasurer’s report: The annual P&L and Balance sheet will be presented at the AGM following this meeting. Alison presented the Forward Financial plan for the year to end March-27 which shows a surplus of £300.

South Meadows Action Group : The next report comes out tomorrow 25th. They met last week and have been informed that the Bin Hub locations were outsourced to a London company! They have asked for a Freedom of Info request to further this and have started up a TwitterX account with over 2000 subscribers already.

Meetings attended: No other meetings attended

AOCB: Brian brought up the concern of the JGHS playing fields being so noisy at night as kids climb over the walls. The Cllr response was that there was no night security there. Brian to push this again.

Brian had heard from a local resident about the shocking state of weeds on/in the streets and pavements. It was suggested we write to complain to the Council and maybe they’d get on to it. Anne said she would check out a group called Better Streets (?) who are active in our area and Alison said she’d check with the Grange Assoc.

Sale of Gillies Centre – Suzie urged that we keep an eye on this. Ian Murray also is monitoring what is happening.

E-Bikes: There was a lot of concern expressed about E-bikes. Lorna Slater said she would check on this – ie. security/accidents/speed etc. More restrictions needed and more enforcement. Cannot be left only to the Police who are over stretched already but more traffic enforcement by Council needed.

Grange Assoc: Anne reported that our previous close contact with Grange Nigel Ayton has moved out the area. Suggests we need stronger links with the GA. Alison to contact them to see if they can have a representative attend our meetings more regularly.

Anthony Holmes reported that the defibrillator at the Kilgraston church is currently out of action due to parts to be replaced.

The date of the next meeting is Wednesday 23rd Sept 2026.

All who live or work locally are welcome to attend.



Marchmont and Sciennes Community Council

Minutes of the AGM held on June 24th, 2026 at Sciennes Art Hub, 13 Rillbank Terrace

Sederunt: as for the meeting above.

Chairman’s report: Brian reported that 3 new councillors were now actively working with the MSCC – and more would be welcomed. He also welcomed Kate McNairney as the SMAG representative and Douglas Rogers as the newly created post of Inclusion Officer.

Meetings had been well attended in the year and had covered many subjects and projects, not least the installation of the Defibrillator outside The Optician in Marchmont, the installation at last of the toilet block on the Meadows, discussions on the Sick Kids development site and the road closure for Sciennes Primary School, and the opening of the Sciennes Arts Hub.

He extended thanks to Anne for all her hard work as Secretary, to Alison as Treasurer and for organising the popular Christmas event, to Douglas for the considerable work involved as Inclusion Officer, and last but by no means least to Kayleigh and Liane for their help in generating publicity and awareness for the MSCC.

Secretary’s Report: Anne reported the good news that the Sylvan Place works were now completed so no more disruption for the residents. She reported that the Council City Parks dept were providing plants for the local tubs and she and Norah (local resident) had done the planting. The ones at the top of Marchmont Crescent were now being done by local shopkeepers there using Council plants. She also reported that the Marchmont/Sciennes sewage works are now completed – we are awaiting MSCC Noticeboard improvements – a new defibrillator is installed on the north wall of the Meadows toilet block – Reid Memorial and Marchmont St Giles churches have merged and are now called Blackford & Grange Church.

Treasurers’ Report: Alison presented the P&L and Balance sheet duly signed off by the Independent Reviewer Jim Orr, showing a surplus for the year of £873 compared to last year’s deficit of £979. The previous year’s deficit was due to us not receiving the CC grant in the period. However, we received a double grant in the year to end March-26.

She proposed that a thank you donation of a plant (£20-25) for Jim Orr’s garden and this was agreed.

Election of Officer: Chair – Brian was proposed by various people and there being no other proposals accepted the position and was duly elected.

Secretary – Anne was proposed by various people and there being no other proposals accepted the position and was duly elected.

Treasurer – Alison was proposed by various people and there being no other proposals accepted the position and was duly elected.

Inclusion Officer – Douglas was proposed by various people and there being no other proposals accepted the position and was duly elected.

Publicity team: Leane and Kayleigh are willing to continue in the role and this was duly confirmed

Date of next AGM: Wednesday 23rd June 2027

Tuesday, 15 September 2026

MSCC Draft Agenda for 23rd September 2026

 

M archmont & Sciennes

Community Council




Meeting on Wed 23rd September 2026 at 7:30pm

To be held at Sciennes Art Hub, 8a Sciennes Road EH9 1LE

A G E N D A



1 Sederunt and apologies

2   Draft Minutes of last meeting June 2026

actions and matters arising (not otherwise on the agenda)

3. Update from Astley Ainslie Community Trust, Keith Anderson

4 Meadows & Bruntsfield Links

5 Publicity

6 City Councillor report on topical local issues

7 Inclusion Officer’s report (attached)



Items for discussion

8 Planning

9 progress on pedestrian crossing assessment (Argyle Place)

For info:

10 Treasurer's report (attached)

  1. Defibrillator costs

11 SMAG report

12 Meetings attended

13 AOCB

14 Date of next meeting: Wednesday 22nd October 2026



Please note new venue for the meeting. Access easiest from Sciennes



All who live or work locally are welcome to attend

Wednesday, 24 June 2026

MSCC - Minutes from May 2026

 



Marchmont and Sciennes Community Council

Minutes of Meeting held on May 27th, 2026 at Sciennes Art Hub, 13 Rillbank Terrace

 

Present

Alison Service - MSCC Treasurer Chairing

Geoff Parsons – MSCC

Anne Laing MSCC

Kate McNairney SMAG

Douglas Roger MSCC

Anthony Holmes MSCC

Peter Olech MSCC

Richard Shilcock MSCC

Cllr Steve Burgess

Cllr Mandy Watt

Becky Marsland Local resident

Norah Rogers Local Resident



Apologies

Brian Gilmore – MSCC Chair

Suizie Agnew

Cllr Marie Claire Munro

Ian Murray MP

Attending

Hannah Walsh - Minutes Secretary

Meeting began at 19:32 pm.



Sederunt and apologies

Alison welcomes everyone to the meeting. Sederunt and apologies as above.



Draft Minutes of last meeting April 2026

Geoff moves to approve the minutes. Peter seconds. 



Actions and matters arising (not otherwise on Agenda)

Matters arising

Suzie wrote regarding the Grange cemetery closing time of 5 pm suggested the MSCC ask that it stay open until 7pm in summer – ALISON TO ACTION.

Suzie also wrote to Ian Murray MP about ROYAL MAIL collections from the Falcon Road delivery office opening times but has not heard back yet. Cllr Mandy Watt for Morningside will follow up on this matter.

Suggested donation to SMAG for expenses: SMAG currently pay for hiring of halls for public meetings, printing and photography among other expenses. The agreed donation by the MSCC is £150. Kate will provide Alison with the invoices and information necessary to process this request.

Meadows & Bruntsfield Links:

The Hamish Henderson walkway has been approved by Edinburgh Council who have emailed all locals in case of objections but otherwise it will go ahead.

The AGM for Friends of the Meadows is on June the 19th at 6.30 the German Church Hall.

The Meadow’s Festival: is to be held on the 6th and 7th of June. There will be an information stand for FOMBL and CCs at the festival, contact Alison if you can help man this with a 2hour slot. Information for MSCC and Friends of the Meadows will be at the booth.

Volunteering for FOMBL: every Saturday meeting at the Pavilion at 10 o’clock if anyone wants to volunteer, council resources are limited so volunteers are vital, contact Alison if interested.

The Marchmont Hardware Shop is undergoing repair works till end May and should be re-opening soon.

Publicity : No report.



City Councillor report on topical local issues

Cllr Mandy Watt : Update on participatory budgeting

Visitor levy: originally to be spread equally as £20,000 per ward but this has been revised and now is variable depending on need so currently unsure what the Marchmont Sciennes area will receive. It was expressed that with the Meadows the hope is that the area will receive the full £20,000. Alison said that FOMBL will lobby for more to be given to the Meadows.

Community grants have just reopened. White House Loan safe to school route will be made permanent, Council going to apply to put one in Clinton Road also and reapply for the one in Caanan lane. It is also expected that the street lighting in White House Loan be improved to help with safety and improve visibility.

Cllr Steve Burgess - Political landscape of Marchmont and Sciennes post the election

Prior to the election the MSCC was in the Edinburgh southern constituency after the election the boundary changed, and the Edinburgh central constituency was extended to now include Marchmont and Sciennes.

The new constituency MSP is Lorna Slater of the Green Party, defeating incumbent Angus Roberston’s SNP. Lorna has asked to come meet with the MSCC. It was uniformly agreed to invite Ms Slater to come when she can. Cllr Burgess will contact to invite her to the June or September onwards meeting.

There are 7 regional MSPs elected who represent the area, residents can contact any of them for matters affecting the area that are decided at Parliament level. They are:

Irshad Ahmed, Miles Briggs, Kayleigh Kinross, Q. Manivannan, Kate Nevens and Angela Ross

There are changes at City Council as four Councillors were elected to MSP including Samita Kumar. Initially Councillors said they would continue in both roles, but Samita may step down as she is a Minister and trigger a by election in the area.

Council members express dissatisfaction about double jobbing. Cllr Watt will confirm if they take their MSP salary plus Councillor remuneration – but thinks this is unlikely.

There was a suggestion made for more public toilets on the Meadows; the new ones have been damaged with the back wall broken. Council should review design, as poor decision made not to install a gent's urinal causing big queues. More urinals would make everything cheaper and more efficient. The project spent £350,000 for 4 individual cubicles with one for disabled only available with special request call. MSCC members dissatisfied with the cost of this and that there was not aggressive enough purchasing or transparent procurement process. The same issue is seen in Inverleith park regarding public toilets. Alison to put this this to FoMBL.

Inclusion Officer’s report (attached)

Douglas reported that he completed the response for MSCC to the questionnaire for community level democracy - most people preferred option B marginally over option C (See report).

ApartHotel planning: For more detail see report. Great number of residents expressed dissatisfaction to the planning being granted. It is important for community to develop a policy on tourism in the area to help campaigns and lobbying going forward. In the planning committee meeting that granted the planning for the aparthotel the Council also threw out 43 applications for short term lets. Geoff expresses that the Council's objective should always be affordable housing, while Douglas states that the issue in this case was the land is owned by a private company. There are certain stipulations in planning to protect and provide community spaces, example including the meeting venue Sciennes arts hub; that is only available due to planning rules for private developers.

There was discussion on the number of objections need to meaningfully block a planning application as this case received over 130 from residents. Cllr Burgess explains that objections only force the development and management subcommittee to review the application in more depth but its ultimately up to their discretion and even if not granted can be appealed at parliament.

Alison asks about feasibility for MSCC and other community councils to be able to change the legislation. Geoff states if we want affordable housing we should have more compulsory purchase orders on development land. This would need governmental intervention. An example is the Irish system that allows third party appeal after applications granted. The Scottish government recently voted against this change of legislation. Leith community council have been lobbying against aparthotels. MSCC agree to review how to move forward to make things better in the future. An agreement was reached that it is easier to argue an alternative plan than a complete blockage of planning applications in this category, this will help with lobbying. Alison suggests bringing it forward and liaising with Leith.

BANZAI group: Group ask MSCC to support them for applying for green light funding that provides grants for sustainability projects. One of their main goals is to look at environmental issues that affect the area and ask MSCC along with Merchiston CC if they will support the application for the funding. They are not requesting money from MSCC. The group are going to apply for £15,000 for their projects. It was unanimously agreed that the MSCC support their application.

The heat networks in building adjacent to the Sciennes Arts Hub current price is 27ppKW and Douglas is currently evaluating local heat networks to determine why they are so expensive. Other Council heat networks that have been shown to have efficiency of 25%. Douglas is conducting this research as part of Lothian heat.



Items for discussion

Planning: There are lots of short term lets applications being turned down.



Treasurer’s report (attached) : The end April balance is £1238.06. MSCC donated £100 to FoMBL for the Hamish Henderson Walkway signage.



SMAG report : SMAG put in 16 submissions from the community after meeting with Cllr Steven Jenkinson. His reply can be seen in their newsletter, nothing was changed. Group going to continue to work to get support, develop website and social media. 2,000 people have engaged. SMAG would appreciate in being more involved in the process with the City Council going forward even if they decide not to change things.

Meetings attended: No meetings attended

AOCB: None arising

The date of the next meeting is Wednesday 24th of June 2026 – AGM and general meeting .

All who live or work locally are welcome to attend.

Friday, 12 June 2026

MSCC - Minutes from April 2026

 

Marchmont and Sciennes Community Council

Minutes of Meeting held on April 22nd, 2026 at St. Catherine’s Argyle Church Hall

Present

Brian Gilmore - MSCC Chair

Alison Service - MSCC Treasurer

Douglas Rogers - MSCC Inclusion Officer

Susie Agnew - MSCC

Geoff Parsons - MSCC

Peter Olech - MSCC

Cllr Tim Pogson


Apologies

Anne Laing - MSCC Secretary

Kate McNairney - SMAG

Kayleigh Gordon & Liane Phillips - MSCC Publicity


Attending

Eli Ferrell - Minutes Secretary


Meeting began at 19:33pm.


Sederunt and apologies

Brian welcomes everyone to the meeting. Sederunt and apologies as above.


Draft Minutes of last meeting March 2026

Peter moves to approve the minutes. Alison seconds.


Actions and matters arising (not otherwise on Agenda)

Suggested donation to SMAG: this information is being put together at the moment, so this item will be held to the next meeting.


The Argyle Pl/Melville Drive junction will be added to the Council's list of suggested improvements, and the traffic signals team will review the timings of this junction and make improvements if possible, either now or at the next time this junction is scheduled for improvements.


Post office depot letter included a justification in regards to which postcodes each available office controls. There is a question as to why EH9 cannot be reassigned to Falkland Road entirely. Susie will action this question by writing to Ian Murray.


In regards to the community grant mentioned in the last meeting, the recommended grant is not within our area and would require additional liaison with the Council. It was agreed that the MSCC stick to the original plan of donating £100 to FOMBL and suggesting they apply to Morningside CC for an additional donation.


Meadows & Bruntsfield Links


Publicity

No publicity report.


City Councillor report ::

Cllr Pogson reported that the council, in response to criticism about bad landlords has, at the last meeting, struck four off due to criminal records and persistent failure to remedy living conditions, and one other has a chance to attend the next meeting to make her case to avoid being struck off (note that only three landlords were struck off in the entirety of last year). When a landlord is struck off, they must sell their properties, which could result in an eviction of current tenants. If tenants are living in substandard conditions, they should refer their landlord to the council.


Astley Ainslie Hospital’s place plan has been lodged and both the NHS and the council are producing their vision for the site as well.


In the recently approved budget, the council has introduced a 400% council tax uplift on second homes, given that there is a housing emergency. Due to backlash, this policy has been paused for six months while an impact assessment is carried out. There is some concern over this policy from MSCC as this tax also applies to empty homes during renovations.


Inclusion Officer’s report (attached)

Sciennes ArtsHub

Thanks to Tim for easing the way to get the IQ Students space. Currently the space can be used for Arts teaching and Community Council meetings. Potential activities will increase once noise reduction installments take place. MSCC agrees that from next month, Community Council meetings will take place in that space. For more detail on the IQ students space proposed activities, please see the attached report.


Key Updates from Democracy Matters:

A plan was circulated on how to empower local communities with three options on how to decide the funding criteria. As Community councils must vote for their preferred option by the 4th of May it was agreed that Douglas will email all members of MSCC to vote on the option they prefer.


Heat networks

Douglas is now working with Lothian Heat to identify heat networks in Edinburgh so that Lothian Heat can support these smaller heat networks.


Geoff flags that new builds are not contributing to heat networks right now, although Douglas flags that new builds should be banned from using gas. Cllr Pogson notes that the heat from the Edinburgh/Midlothian landfill incendiary is currently used to power turbines, but there is infrastructure building taking place for excess heat to support local heat networks.


Planning

No relevant planning reports.


Treasurer’s report (attached)

Last month’s balance of £1632 is down to £1338 due to payments for the insurance, hall hire, and minutes secretary. From May onwards the hall hire will be the new Sciennes ArtsHub.


SMAG report

No report this week.


Meetings attended

No meetings attended.


AOCB

The end of year accounts will go to the external reviewer in April. The AGM will take place in June.


The date of the next meeting is Wednesday 27th of May at Sciennes Arts Centre, 13 Rillbank Terrace.


All who live or work locally are welcome to attend.


MSCC - Draft Agenda+AGM for 24th June

 

M archmont & Sciennes

Community Council




Meeting on Wed 24th June 2026 at 7:30pm

To be held at Sciennes Art Hub, 13 Rillbank Terr

A G E N D A



1 Sederunt and apologies

2   Draft Minutes of last meeting May 2026

actions and matters arising (not otherwise on

3 Meadows & Bruntsfield Links

4 Publicity

5 City Councillor report on topical local issues

6 Inclusion Officer’s report (attached)

Items for discussion

7 Planning

For info:

8 Treasurer's report (attached)

9 SMAG report

10 Meetings attended

11 AOCB

a. Grange cemetery opening hours: suggest extending from 5 to 7pm in Summer

12 Date of next meeting: Wednesday 23rd September 2026



Annual General Meeting

  1. Annual report from Chairman

  2. Annual report from Secretary

  3. Annual report from Treasurer and presentation of audited accounts

  4. Election of Officers

  5. Date of next AGM : Wednesday 23rd June 2027



Please note new venue for the meeting. Access easiest from Sciennes



All who live or work locally are welcome to attend

Monday, 18 May 2026

MSCC - Minutes for March 2026

 

Marchmont and Sciennes Community Council

Minutes of Meeting held on March 25th, 2026 at St. Catherine’s Argyle Church Hall

Present

Brian Gilmore - MSCC chair

Alison Service - MSCC Treasurer

Anne Laing - MSCC Secretary

Douglas Rogers - MSCC Inclusion Officer

Kate McNairney - SMAG

David Somervell - Bruntsfield Area Net Zero Action

Margaret Coughtrie - Local resident

Sara Kondracki - Local resident

Bethan Morgan - Local resident

Geoff Parsons - MSCC

Anthony Holmes - MSCC

Richard Shillcock - MSCC


Apologies

Peter Olech - MSCC

Kayleigh Gordon & Liane Phillips - MSCC Publicity

Susie Agnew - MSCC

Cllr Ben Parker


Attending

Eli Ferrell - Minutes Secretary


Meeting began at 19:34pm.


Sederunt and apologies

Brian welcomes everyone to the meeting. Sederunt and apologies as above.


Draft Minutes of last meeting February 2026

Susie Agnew was added to the minutes as having attended the February meeting. Alison moves to approve the minutes. Anne seconds.


Actions and matters arising (not otherwise on Agenda)

A letter has been circulated from the post office about the depot (by way of Cllr Marie-Clair Murro). No further action to be taken.


There is now access to the defibrillator outside the optician’s at Marchmont, corrected after a few days of prevented access, despite the large hole in the pavement. The optician’s basement roof was punctured and he was flooded out, but minimal action has been taken. Anne will write to the four councillors in Morningside ward (Marie-Clair Murro, Ben Parker, Neil Ross, and Mandy Watt) to complain about the way these works have been handled.


Anne contacted Sgt Lumsden expressing the MSCC dismay at the recent graffiti incident at the Mosque.


Meadows & Bruntsfield Links

FOMBL report has been circulated. FOMBL has agreed that the walkway will be named Hamish Henderson Way, in accordance with the MSCC vote. The nameplate will cost upwards of £400 pounds. Alison suggests a £100 donation. It is noted that Peter Olech suggested an application for EC Community Grants Fund in that matter. Alison will apply for that grant.


There are apple trees all along North Meadow Walk, and cherry trees down the diagonal path. It is unclear if there will be sufficient water if there is a hard summer. MSCC could go back to FOMBL and note their concern about whether there will be enough water.


Publicity

No publicity report.


City Councillor report on topical local issues

No councillors attending.

Danger to pedestrians and cyclists crossing Argyle Place near Melville Drive:A local resident Bethan Morgan presented a draft that was circulated to members earlier about the dangers of the crossing at foot of Argyle Pl and Melville Drive. There was general agreement at the meeting that this area needs to be revisited by road planners before there is a serious accident and Anne and Bethan will compose a suitable document to be sent to the local Councillors


Margaret Coughtrie expressed concern about the work being carried out at Summerhall/Melville Terrace and is not aware of the plans being circulated before work started and Melville Terrace was closed. It is noted that the plans had been circulated on a TTRO. These are for improvements for pedestrians and cycle path in that area; the work will be carried out in phases and is likely to take quite a long time.


The order to close Whitehouse Loan outside James Gillespie’s might expire the 15th of June. It is noted that the road closures made during COVID are being reviewed, but it was also believed that the Whitehouse Loan closure was permanent. Individual members of the community are encouraged to write in about it in advance of the review on April 2nd if they are concerned about the lapse.


It is raised that there should be a commitment from the Council to resurface Fingal Place; it is currently dangerous to cyclists and motorists, as well as potential causing damage to cars. Rat-running has recommenced at high speed. Geoff will draft a complaint.


Inclusion Officer’s report (attached)

Community Space

There is finally a final version of the license that will be accepted, despite some flaws, that will be signed in the next week or so. Invites will be distributed for that signing. Once the community space becomes available, there is discussion about doing a pop-up for people to come in and make comments on the Banzai local place plan (see below).


Local Place Plan

On Saturday 28th there will be a free lunch and a world music concert at the Pianodrome intending to take soundings from members of the community on how to pitch City Plan 2040. Please come along, and continue to fill out the survey asking for comments on the local place plan. This locale’s survey can be found here: https://banzaiedinburgh.org.uk/oni2040/


There will be advocacy in this plan to reduce the restrictions on solar panels in the future. There is hope that MSCC will endorse or sign the local place plan once it has been drafted.


Southside Community Council have also initiated a local place plan. Community members who live in that area are welcome to make comments on that plan until the end of May, which can be found here: https://www.sccedinburgh.org.uk/lpp


Morningside Community Council has done a draft, but does not have the funds to publish and circulate a final copy.


Items for discussion

Planning: nothing to note



Treasurer’s report (attached)

One bank account with Virgin successfully remaining (the Bank of Scotland account has been closed) £1632 in the account.


SMAG report

SMAG has been preparing for a meeting with Stephen Jenkinson which took place today about some bins to be closed or moved. There was a good response from SMAG members. The meeting was helpful and presented the five categories listed below:


Five categories raised as concerns about bin hubs

  • Homes without a buffer space (invasive noise or smell)

  • Adjacent to bedrooms; sleep disturbance and family impact

  • Chronic fly tipping

  • Clustered within short distances

  • Loss of use of residential gardens


Only four or five bin hubs will be changed. Stephen Jenkinson has asked for places where there are alternative locations and no one will complain, but that has already been submitted. There is time to get some requests back to him before the next round of TROs. It could still be 18 months to two years before the hubs get moved.


The request is that if anyone has a bin hub that is bothering them and they can think of an alternative location that is not just dumping the bin hub on a neighbour, then notify SMAG ASAP so it can be brought to the next meeting before the next round of TROs.


In the meeting, it was noted that there are more bins required in areas with a lot of HMO living spaces.

Property price drop indicates that people do not want to live around bins.


The issue of bins did come up in one of the place plan meetings—long-term solutions should be proposed to the place plan.


Meetings attended

No meetings attended.


AOCB

Reminder of new City electoral boundaries

When the election comes, this area will be part of Edinburgh Central instead of Edinburgh South. This change is in order to keep the population numbers roughly similar across seats.


Hustings

There will be a husting tomorrow at 7pm on Thursday, March 26th, at the Quaker meeting house.

It is noted that it is very late for MSCC to organize a hustings at this point. Richard and Margaret Coughtrie have volunteered to organize an online husting.


Edinburgh Community Solar Co-operative

There will be a share offer for the next phase of solar panel installation, if you wish to invest or register your interests, go to www.edinburghsolar.coop


The date of the next meeting is Wednesday 22nd of April.


All who live or work locally are welcome to attend.